On Beef Jerky

Notes and observations around making beef jerky.

Meat

Leaner is generally better. Fats in the meat turn rancid and spoil the final product, with fattier cuts spoiling sooner than more lean cuts. Fattier cuts also tend to have more collagen and connective tissue, which is harder to render at dehydration temperatures. This lends to a tougher, stringier chew.

In order of my preferences:

  • Lean Flank
  • Eye round
  • Bottom round (London broil)
  • Top round
  • Brisket flat
  • Skirt

Slicing

When meat dehydrates, the fibers in the muscle dessicate and contract, making the final product chewy and sometimes fibrous. When preparing meats for jerking, slicing the meat across the grain shortens the muscle fibers and connective tissues, allowing the muscle to expel more liquid but remain tender. Slicing meats along the grain tends to render a tougher, more fibrous product.

If slicing with the grain, you may want to tenderize the meat first with a meat hammer, or use a meat tenderizer in the marinade. This will help to break up the long muscle fibers and connective tissues and muscle fibers that make the meat chewy.

Some meats like Flank or Skirt are striated muscles, with bundles of muscle fibers running the length of the cut. When jerked, these cuts may tear or break while dehydrating if cut directly perpendicular to the grain. These cuts in particular work well when slices on a bias against the grain.

Marinade

The meat can be marinated in either a wet brine, or dry rub marinated rub overnight Many of the wet marinade recipes I’ve researched seem rely heavily on Soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce for their salt and umami. Soy sauce contains around 15% salt by weight, depending on the brand and style, and glutamates that give the flavor that “deep, dark roundness” called umami.

Worcestershire contains about 3% salt by weight. It also contains glutamates derived from onion and anchovy. Worcestershire sauce is sweeter than soy sauce, and has a blend of peppers and spices.

Generally, recipes seem to fall around 12% salt and 6% sugar by weight. Where water is added, additional salt is added to maintain 12% salinity.

Note: Sea water is between 5% and 7% salt by weight. Jerky marinades tend to be saltier in part to help cure and tenderize the meat. Many cuts of beef stand up well to a heavy salting.

In my recipes, I mainly rely on a 2:1 blend of Soy Sauce and Tamari, with one additional part of Worcestershire sauce. The combination gives a savory depth without over-expressing the soy flavors.

For sweetness, I use either honey or brown sugar depending in the recipe, though I have considered molasses, teriyaki and Mirin. I tend to like a more savory jerky, so I stick closer to 6% total sugar. Many prefer a sweeter product (e.g., teriyaki) and may find sugar 8% to 10% by weight more palatable.

The remainder of the marinade is spice and aromatics. Many marinades rely on granulated onion and garlic as the backbone, leveraging different pepper blends to round out the flavors. Depending on your preferences, you can also add aromatic herbs such as oregano, thyme or rosemary, and pickling spices such as ginger, allspice, mace or turmeric.

Sometimes liquid smoke is added, if not drying in a smoker.

Curing salts

Some recipes call for curing salt in the form of Morton Tenderquick, or Prague Powder. Curing salts contain nitrates that help to preserve the final product, protecting against spores and bacteria that contribute to botulism and other food borne illnesses. Cured meats have a longer shelf life, and may not require refrigeration.

Tenderquick and Prague Powder are not interchangeable in recipes. Carefully read the instructions for both, and follow the addition rates for the recipes carefully.

I use Prague powder #1 in my marinades at a 0.5% by weight.

Dehydrating

The dehydration process removes moisture from the meat both in the form of water, and in rendered fats that drip from the meat itself. Meat will lose between 50% and 60% of its weight through the dehydration process. That is, a 2 pound cut of beef will render about 1 pound of jerky. Most jerky sits at around 10% water by weight, with drier meats being more brittle and chewy.

When drying the meat, it should be heated between 165°F and 200°F, with good air circulation. The goal is to pasteurize the meat by raising the internal temperature of the above 145°F and holding it for several hours. This process kills any remaining microorganisms that could contribute. to food borne diseases. Fats and collagens begin to render and melt at 165°F, further tenderizing and desiccating the meat. Certain proteins in the meat begin to denature above 190°F and water boils at 212°F, both of which change the character of the final product.

Cooking times are always approximate, as drying time varies with the particular style of cut, thickness of the slices, water content, fat content, air temperature and humidity. Begin checking the meat as early as the earliest estimates, and remove any finished pieces when the complete.

However the product is dried, it is finished when the meat is stiff enough to support itself when held out parallel to the ground, and bends without cracking. Expect some carry-over, as when cooking a roast or a bird. Be careful not to dry the meat too much, as it can become too chewy or leathery.

Oven

The most widely available method to dry jerky is in the oven. Lay the strips out in a single layer and spaced to allow airflow on a cooling rack over a rimmed sheet. Preheat the oven to 175°F and place the pan inside. Maintain heat until the meat is dried, about 5-10 hours

Food dehydrator

Lay strips out in the dehydrator trays in single layers, allowing adequate space between the strips for air flow. Set the dehydrator for 165°F and allow 6-8 hours to dry, rotating stacks occasionally.

Smoker

A smoker provides a more authentic, if more labor intensive drying process. The goal here is to provide a low, even heat, maintaining between 165°F and 190°F, and to impart a smoke flavor without adding too much. Electric smokers in particular can impart a resinous, almost acrid flavor to a product if smoked too hot, or for too long. With wood smoke, plenty is plenty, and less is more.

As with the oven, arrange the slices of meat on a cooling rack over a drip tray, leaving space between for air and smoke to circulate. Preheat the smoker to 170°F, and place the tray.

If using a wet brine, allow 90 minutes without smoke for the meat to sweat and the fats begin to render. After 90 minutes add enough wood to allow for 30 minutes to 60 minutes of smoke abd monitor for a thin blue smoke. After 1 hour, remove the wood and allow 6-10 hours for the meat to dry.

If using a dry brine, add a water pan for the duration.

On Salt & Vinegar (and kettle chips)

Hardly a mad science experiment, but more of a gateway process to unhealthy amounts of sodium in my future diet: Salt & Vinegar seasoning for Salt & Vinegar potato chips.

In the theme of science for science’s sake, let’s talk a minute about vinegar. Typical distilled white vinegar you buy at the local grocer is a solution of about 5% acetic acid (CH3COOH), otherwise known as ethanoic acid. Being an acid, its difficult to apply to starchy foods and vegetables without essentially dissolving or denaturing the intended target. It’s challenging to convert into a powder form. One of the more common industrial methods is to spray a fine mist of acetic acid over a fine bed of maltodextrin– a slightly sweet, neutral carbohydrate that absorbs the acetic acid solution. When dried it’s applied with salt to your favorite kettle chips as a souring agent to give that tangy, vinegar bite.

I don’t exactly eschew industrial methods oi my own home kitchen. I mean, I like junk food, I just don’t like paying for it if I can produce it in a small scale at home. If I can steal a bit of industrial methodology to help cut out the middleman, well, I’m not a purist is what I guess I’m saying. Still, sourcing maltodextrin powder, and then figuring out the proper spray ratio, drying times, processing steps, and all that? Nah. There’s an easier way and, while it’s a little more time consuming, it lends an equivalent product for a fraction of the perceived time I’d spend figuring the whole thing out end-to-end, experimenting, dialing it in and then executing it. The easy way uses common, off-the-shelf ingredients, some grade-school science and a little patience. All you need is vinegar and baking soda.

I’m not going to get into the particulars of the redox reaction that happens, but when you take a 5% solution of acetic acid and sodium bicarbonate (ye Olde Vinegar and Baking Soda), you get a solution of sodium acetate, which is one of the souring agents in a number of brands of Salt & Vinegar potato chips.

In ratio, slowly combine 1.2 liters of distilled white vinegar (acetic acid, 5%) with 42g of baking soda (Na2CO3) to get about a 5% solution of sodium acetate (C2H3NaO2). Then you reduce this solution to a supersaturated volume (about 200ml, if using the full volume) and allow it to crystalize. Dry the crystals and pulverize them into a fine powder which, when rehydrated, produces a vinegar flavor on the tongue.

Having performed this experiment at about half scale (750ml of vinegar with a healthy spoolful of baking soda), I note that I got about 2 oz of sodium acetate powder out of the effort, and it did not knock my socks off. It tasted mildly of vinegar and baking soda, but I was not careful with my ratios.

What did knock my socks off was what happened when I combined the sodium acetate with citric acid and table salt. It turns out that some brands of potato chips use citric acid as a souring agent, and sodium acetate for vinegar flavor. Your tongue is fooled into thinking you’re tasting a pungent vinegar powder, but I now know that to be a lie. A tasty, salty lie. I exposed that lie by combining 1 part cittic acid (1 tbsp) with 2 parts (2 tbsp) sodium acetate and 2 parts (2 tbsp) table salt. To taste it straight from the shaker, it’s a little more sour and rather saltier than straight sodium acetate, but to shake it over fresh kettle chips is to introduce a delightful sour/vinegar and salt taste to the chips. You want to go heavier from the shaker than you might think you want if it was straight salt, and then toss it well. Let the flavors meld a bit (if you can keep the “just a taste” crowd away…) and then serve. Should keep up to 3 or 5 days in a paper bag, assuming they stick around that long.

Now for the chips, this was a pretty typical kettle chip recipe. Eastern potatoes sliced ⅛” thick on a mandolin and soaked in a weak brine to draw out some starch. Then deep-fried in handfuls until lightly golden, cooled and re-fried again until golden brown. Finally, the whole batch gets tossed in this citric acid/sodium acetate/table salt mix and served.

I’ve also tried this salt mix on popcorn, roasted Brussels Sprouts and scrambled eggs. It’s always a treat.

Sodium Acetate instructions

  • (In ratio) 1.2 L distilled white vinegar
  • (in ratio) 42g baking soda

Slowly pour vinegar over baking soda in a non-reactive steel or glass vessel, stirring vigorously until the solution stops foaming and bubbling when agitated

Reduce solution to about 1 tenth of the original volume by microwaving in segments, over an alcohol flame, or in an evaporating pan in a warm oven. Do not overcook if heating. Should reduce to a transparent gel that forms crystals when blown. Allow to cool and form crystals. Remove crystals and dry on a clean coffee filter. Use additional coffee filters until fully dry. Pulverize into a fine powder. Should yield 4 oz.

Vinegar Salt instructions

  • 2 oz table salt
  • 2 oz sodium acetate
  • 1 oz citric acid

Citric acid is available in the canning aisle at most grocery stores.

Combine well and store in an airtight shaker.