Allow me to be the first to say, “rookie move.”
I mentioned in a prior post that I have been chasing a mysterious loss of efficiency in my brew process lately. About a year ago, I acquired a bunch of new equipment and more or less completely changed my brew day process. Around that time, I started using fly sparging instead of batch sparging. I started using BeerSmith 2 to design and track my brews. I also acquired a refractometer that I began using to monitor my mash process. It was about that time I also noticed that my efficiency seemed low for some reason. It seemed reasonable to me that it probably had something to do with the process I was using around the new equipment, and I started to fuss over my gear. Was the sparge arm really working out for me? What a waste of cash! Is the crush right? Try a different brew shop, and another, and another! Are my thermometers reading right? Get new thermometers! Calibrate all the things! Then I started to obsess over the numbers. I was always 15-20 points low on my gravities. I started to dread brew days. I obsessed over little mistakes, which in my mind became the reason this particular brew fell flat. I was making some great beer, sure, but I knew it wasn’t what it could have been. That IPA of mine that you liked was really supposed to be an IIPA. It felt like I was serving lies, and it made me sad.